Census of 1c Green, Perf 12 x 10 (formerly Scott 424a) (Scott 423A)
62 Census Records

Back to Census Summary of 423A

Back to the Siegel Census

1 Sound 2 Fault

423A-OG-01

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 63319 Genuine

423A-OG-02

Notes:

Needs to be re-examined for authenticity

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 35361 Genuine

423A-OG-03

Notes:

Provenance:

12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2002, Realized $2,600

Certificates:

PF 33214 Part o.g., thin spot at right

423A-OG-04

Notes:

Provenance:

6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 151, Realized $6,250
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2001

Certificates:

PF 155250 Genuine
PF 408389 Genuine PH

423A-OG-05

Notes:

Provenance:

Needs to be re-examined for authenticity

Certificates:

PF 126606 Genuine

423A-OG-06

Notes:

Provenance:

5/2000, Rubin Collection, Matthew Bennet Auctions, Lot 302

Certificates:

PF 93225 Genuine

423A-OG-07

Notes:

Provenance:

9/12/2000, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 826, Lot 682, Realized $1,800
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 152, Realized $5,250

Certificates:

PF 312290 (1997) Genuine PH
PF 482122 (2009) Genuine, PH

423A-OG-08

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 48607 Genuine

423A-OG-09

Notes:

Provenance:

5/13/2000, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2000 Rarities of the World, Sale 824, Lot 311, Realized $1,600

Certificates:

P.S.E. (1999)

423A-OG-BL-01

Notes:

Provenance:

11/2003, Matthew Bennet Auctions, Lot 1262, Realized $23,100
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2003, Unsold
12/10/2015, Kelleher, Sale 676
6/30-7/1/2020, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2020 Rarities of the World, Sale 1224, Lot 200, Unsold

Certificates:

PF 401872 Genuine, previously hinged
PF 533360 (2015) bottom stamps NH
PSE 01305180 (2015) bottom stamps NH

423A-OG-BL-02
Fault

Notes:

Provenance:

12/8/2015, Kelleher, Lot 1354, Realized $18,800, " top stamps each with tiny thin", realized

Certificates:

PF 533360 (2015) IT IS GENUINE, THE BOTTOM STAMPS NEVER HINGED, THE TOP STAMPS PREVIOUSLY HINGED, AND BOTH WITH A TINY THIN.
PSE 1305180 (2015)

423A-OG-PR-O1

Notes:

9820 “Genuine pair”

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 468664 Genuine, the top stamp with disturbed o.g. and a small thin at upper right; the bottom stamp previously hinged

423A-OG-PR-O2

Notes:

Provenance:

10/1946, Colonel Green Collection, Costales
12/8/2004, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps and Covers, Sale 889, Lot 1498, Realized $7,000
2/23-24/2015, Curtis Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Curtis Collection: U.S. 20th Century and Air Post, Sale 1093, Lot 287, Realized $6,750

Certificates:

PF 421542 (2005) Genuine, Never Hinged
PF 526508 (2015) Genuine, Never Hinged

423A-CAN-01

Notes:

Provenance:

5/19/2001, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2001 Rarities of the World, Sale 837, Lot 298, Realized $3,500
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 157, Realized $6,750
5/8-9/2008, Hoffman Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Jay Hoffman Collection of United States Stamps, Sale 956, Lot 415, Realized $10,500

Certificates:

PF 313956 Genuine

423A-CAN-02

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 255194 Gen., light vertical crease
PF 290523 Genuine

423A-CAN-03

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 228257 Genuine, creases

423A-CAN-04

Notes:

Provenance:

12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2013, Realized $1,800
11/9-11/2016, Siegel Auction Galleries, Outstanding United States Stamps, featuring The Irwin Weinberg Inventory, Sale 1140, Lot 850, Realized $1,400

Certificates:

PF 308804 Genuine

423A-CAN-05

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 37479 Genuine, vertical crease

423A-CAN-06

Notes:

Provenance:

11/30/1971, Grunin Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Louis Grunin Gold Medal Collection of 20th Century, Sale 404, Lot 268, Realized $150
9/12/2000, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 826, Lot 683, Realized $3,000
11/14-16/2018, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps including Confederate States and Hawaii, Sale 1192, Lot 482, Realized $3,750

Certificates:

PF 37579 (1972) Genuine
PF 211876 (1989) Genuine
PSE (2018) Genuine
PF 582724 (2021) Genuine, Graded 80

423A-CAN-07

Notes:

Faint diagonal crease (not mentioned on certificate).

Provenance:

11/14-16/2018, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps including Confederate States and Hawaii, Sale 1192, Lot 483, Realized $2,200

Certificates:

PF 140536 (1985) Genuine

423A-CAN-08

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 93233 Genuine

423A-CAN-09

Notes:

Provenance:

12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2014, Realized $1,600

Certificates:

PF 312291 Genuine, light diagonal crease

423A-CAN-10

Notes:

Provenance:

5/15/1999, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1999 Rarities of the World, Sale 811, Lot 189, Realized $2,100
12/13/1999, Puliafito Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S. Stamps incl. The Carmen A. Puliafito Collection, Sale 818, Lot 243, Realized $3,500
4/10/2001, Twigg-Smith Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Thurston Twigg-Smith Collection of Superb Used U.S. Stamps, Sale 835, Lot 428, Realized $2,700
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 156, Realized $6,500
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2010, Unsold

Certificates:

PF 94975 Genuine, slight crease, at left
PF 342200 Genuine, light diagonal crease

423A-CAN-11

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 97858 Genuine

423A-CAN-12

Notes:

Provenance:

12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2012, Realized $2,300

Certificates:

PF 189788 Genuine, light horizontal crease

423A-CAN-13

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 308039 Genuine, some bottom perfs trimmed away by scissors

423A-CAN-14

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 39236 Genuine

423A-CAN-15

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 269354 Genuine

423A-CAN-16

Notes:

Provenance:

2/27/2002, Siegel Auction Galleries, Outstanding U.S. Stamps, Sale 843, Lot 1953, Realized $7,500
9/20/2012, Natalee Grace Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Natalee Grace Collection of Used U.S. Stamps, Part Three: 1902 and Later Issues, Sale 1028, Lot 382, Realized $4,500

Certificates:

PF 45534 (1974) Genuine
PF 382797 (2002)
PF 507539 (2012) Genuine, Graded 80

423A-CAN-17

Notes:

Provenance:

5/19/2001, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2001 Rarities of the World, Sale 837, Lot 299, Realized $3,250
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 155, Realized $5,500

Certificates:

PF 66141 (1978) Gen., slight thinning
PF 373571 (2001) Gen., slight thinning
PF 482123 (2009) Genuine with thins

423A-CAN-18

Notes:

Provenance:

2/23-24/2015, Curtis Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Curtis Collection: U.S. 20th Century and Air Post, Sale 1093, Lot 288, Realized $2,800

Certificates:

PF 83901 Genuine, thin

423A-CAN-19
Sound

Notes:

Provenance:

4/29-30/2021, Gary Petersen Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Gary Petersen Collection of Important United States Stamps, Sale 1234, Lot 329, Realized $3,250

Certificates:

PF 81604 (1980) Genuine
PF 401191 (2003) Genuine

423A-CAN-20

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 112940 Genuine

423A-CAN-21

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 97855 Genuine, creasing and repaired area at left

423A-CAN-22

Notes:

Provenance:

5/19/2001, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2001 Rarities of the World, Sale 837, Lot 300, Realized $3,250
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 158, Realized $4,250
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2017, Unsold

Certificates:

PF 373572 “Genuine, small tear at left

423A-CAN-PCE-23

Notes:

Provenance:

10/8-10/1998, Zoellner Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Robert Zoellner Collection of United States, Sale 804, Lot 615, Realized $2,000

Certificates:

PF 331718 Genuine

423A-CAN-24
Fault

Notes:

Provenance:

10/15-18/2001, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 839, Lot 1543, Realized $1,600

Certificates:

PF 590922 (2022) Genuine with a repaired tear at top left and corner creases at top left and bottom left

423A-CAN-25

Notes:

Provenance:

10/15-18/2001, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 839, Lot 1542, Realized $4,250
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2009

Certificates:

PF 493447 Genuine, reperfed at top

423A-CAN-PCE-26

Notes:

Provenance:

10/2001, Floyd Collection, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Realized $15,000
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 153, Realized $30,000
6/24/2021, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2021 Rarities of the World, Sale 1239, Lot 628, Realized $6,750

Certificates:

APS 1512 (1955) Genuine
PF 378606 (2001) Genuine
PF 578091 (2021) It is a genuine usage

423A-CAN-27

Notes:

Provenance:

11/30/1971, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Louis Grunin Gold Medal Collection of 20th Century, Sale 404, Grunin

Certificates:

423A-CAN-28

Notes:

Provenance:

6/1940, Ewing Collection, H.R. Harmer, Lot 812
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 154, Realized $11,500
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2004

Certificates:

PF 379013 Genuine

423A-CAN-29

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 9900 Genuine

423A-CAN-30

Notes:

Provenance:

6/7/2008, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2008 Rarities of the World, Sale 958, Lot 673, Realized $8,500
6/19/2010, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2010 Rarities of the World, Sale 989, Lot 186, Realized $3,500, “light crease at bottom left visible only in fluid”
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2016, Unsold

Certificates:

PF 15716 Genuine
PF 466604 Genuine

423A-CAN-31

Notes:

Provenance:

6/7/2008, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2008 Rarities of the World, Sale 958, Lot 674, Realized $5,000
6/25/2013, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2013 Rarities of the World, Sale 1048, Lot 351, Realized $3,000

Certificates:

PF 464111 Genuine, small corner crease at top right

423A-CAN-32

Notes:

Provenance:

6/23-25/2008, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 959, Lot 2865, Realized $9,000

Certificates:

PF (1958)

423A-CAN-33

Notes:

Provenance:

6/13/2009, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2009 Rarities of the World, Sale 973, Lot 203, Realized $5,250
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2011, Unsold
5/10/2022, Kelleher, U.S. and Worldwide Stamps, Covers and Collections, Sale 769, Lot 5353

Certificates:

PF 476054 (2009) Genuine

423A-CAN-34

Notes:

Formerly the right stamp in pair with 423A-CAN-33

Provenance:

12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2005

Certificates:

PF 264024 Genuine, perfs mostly separated, as pair
P.S.E. (2007), Graded 70

423A-CAN-35

Notes:

Formerly the right stamp in pair with 423A-CAN-33

Provenance:

6/19/2010, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2010 Rarities of the World, Sale 989, Lot 185, Realized $3,250

Certificates:

PF 264024 Genuine, perfs mostly separated, as pair
P.S.E. as a single (2007), Graded 70

423A-CAN-36

Notes:

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 461911 Genuine, with a small thin spot at top, a tiny corner perforation crease left and a light vertical crease at right

423A-CAN-37

Notes:

Provenance:

12/16-18/2009, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 982, Lot 5811, Realized $7,000

Certificates:

PF 317816 Genuine
PF 484265 Genuine

423A-CAN-BL-01

Notes:

Provenance:

4/10/2001, Twigg-Smith Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Thurston Twigg-Smith Collection of Superb Used U.S. Stamps, Sale 835, Lot 429, Realized $10,500
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 160, Realized $19,000
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2007, Unsold
10/22/2019, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 1209, Lot 1261, Realized $12,000

Certificates:

PF 46412 (1974) Genuine
PF 373573 (2001) Genuine
PF 564976 (2019)

423A-CAN-PR-01

Notes:

Provenance:

3/23/2016, Kelleher, Sale 681, Lot 1848, Unsold
7/29/2021, Rumsey, Sale 97, Lot 1633, Realized $4,500

Certificates:

PF 93223 (1980) Genuine
PF 579544 (2021) Genuine with a diagonal crease on right stamp at top right corner

423A-CAN-PR-02

Notes:

NOT GENUINE AS PER LATEST PF CERTIFICATE

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 250621 Genuine reperfed at top
PF 426911 Not Scott 423A, but rather Scott 424 with counterfeit perfs at top and bottom, left stamp with creases at top left

423A-CAN-PR-03

Notes:

Provenance:

12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2006, Realized $3,000

Certificates:

PF 243718 (1991) Genuine, right stamp vertical crease
PF 494852 (2011) Genuine left stamp light vertical crease

423A-CAN-PR-04

Notes:

Provenance:

5/15/1999, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1999 Rarities of the World, Sale 811, Lot 190, Realized $2,200
5/18/2002, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2002 Rarities of the World, Sale 846, Lot 2304, Realized $4,250

Certificates:

PF 17133 Genuine

BROKEN

Notes:

broken - see singles CAN33 and CAN34

Provenance:

Certificates:

423A-CAN-PR-06

Notes:

Never certified

Provenance:

10/15-18/2001, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 839, Lot 1544, Realized $5,250, “left stamp few short perfs at B., R stamp vertical paper wrinkle”
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2015, Unsold

Certificates:

423A-CAN-PR-07

Notes:

Needs to be re-examined for authenticity

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 237232 counterfeit horizontal perfs

423A-COV-01

Notes:

Provenance:

11/30/1971, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Louis Grunin Gold Medal Collection of 20th Century, Sale 404, Lot 269, Grunin

Certificates:

PF 37578 Genuine, top stamp piece off at top left

423A-COV-02

Notes:

Provenance:

6/24/2021, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2021 Rarities of the World, Sale 1239, Lot 629, Realized $3,250
4/1989, Siskin Collection, Superb Auctions, Lot 118
10/8-10/1998, Zoellner Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Robert Zoellner Collection of United States, Sale 804, Lot 616, Realized $3,750
9/12/2000, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 826, Lot 681, Realized $3,250
6/12/2004, Chesapeake Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Chesapeake Collection of Compound Perforations, Sale 877, Lot 161, Realized $9,500
12/9/2010, Sirron Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Sirron Collection of U.S. Perforation Rarities, Sale 1001, Lot 2008, Unsold

Certificates:

PF 331892 (1998) Genuine, light file fold at center
PF 578094 (2021) It is a genuine usage with a light pocket fold

423A-COV-03

Notes:

Provenance:

5/31/2003, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2003 Rarities of the World, Sale 863, Lot 554A, Realized $7,500
6/25/2013, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2013 Rarities of the World, Sale 1048, Lot 352, Realized $6,000

Certificates:

PSE 83932 (2002) Genuine
PF 513850 (2013) Genuine, the card with a vertical crease at left

423A-COV-04

Notes:

Tied by "Chicago Ill. Dec. 23, 1914" machine cancel on Christmas picture post card to Oregon Wis.

Provenance:

Certificates:

PSE 01090769 (2007)
PF 510588 (2013) Genuine usage

Back to Census Summary of 423A

Back to the Siegel Census

Census of 1c Green, Perf 12 x 10 (formerly Scott 424a) (Scott 423A)62 Census Records

423A-OG-01

423A-OG-02

423A-OG-03

423A-OG-04

423A-OG-05

423A-OG-06

423A-OG-07

423A-OG-08

423A-OG-09

423A-OG-BL-01

423A-OG-BL-02 Fault

423A-OG-PR-O1

423A-OG-PR-O2

423A-CAN-01

423A-CAN-02

423A-CAN-03

423A-CAN-04

423A-CAN-05

423A-CAN-06

423A-CAN-07

423A-CAN-08

423A-CAN-09

423A-CAN-10

423A-CAN-11

423A-CAN-12

423A-CAN-13

423A-CAN-14

423A-CAN-15

423A-CAN-16

423A-CAN-17

423A-CAN-18

423A-CAN-19 Sound

423A-CAN-20

423A-CAN-21

423A-CAN-22

423A-CAN-PCE-23

423A-CAN-24 Fault

423A-CAN-25

423A-CAN-PCE-26

423A-CAN-27

423A-CAN-28

423A-CAN-29

423A-CAN-30

423A-CAN-31

423A-CAN-32

423A-CAN-33

423A-CAN-34

423A-CAN-35

423A-CAN-36

423A-CAN-37

423A-CAN-BL-01

423A-CAN-PR-01

423A-CAN-PR-02

423A-CAN-PR-03

423A-CAN-PR-04

BROKEN

423A-CAN-PR-06

423A-CAN-PR-07

423A-COV-01

423A-COV-02

423A-COV-02

423A-COV-03

423A-COV-04

Census of 1c Green, Perf 12 x 10 (formerly Scott 424a) (Scott 423A)
62 Census Records

423A-OG-BL-02
Fault

423A-CAN-19
Sound

423A-CAN-24
Fault