Census of $500.00 Red Orange, Green & Black, Second Issue, "Large Persian Rug" (Scott R133)
87 Census Records

Back to Census Summary of R133

Back to the Siegel Census

22 Sound 65 Fault

1-1
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "EC, July 7, 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Small ink spot on gum in left margin. Selvage at left and right.

Provenance:

1986, Frajola Private Treaty
10/9/2002, Drucker Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Drucker Family Collection, Part 1: U.S. Stamps, Sale 851, Lot 657, Realized $19,000
12/2/2005, Bennett, Sale 297, Lot 3271, Realized $28,000
11/1/2006, Heritage, Sale 998297, Lot 3271, Realized $28,000
12/16/2014, Curtis Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Curtis Collection: U.S. Revenues, Part 1, Sale 1089, Lot 473, Realized $50,000

Certificates:

PF (1986)
PF (2002)

1-2
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "EC, July 7th, 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book. Selvage at left and right.

Provenance:

Certificates:

PF 459829

1-3
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "EC, July 7th, 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book. Selvage at left and right. Light creases in selvage.

Provenance:

10/5/2016, Inman Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Grant Inman Collection, Part 3: First, Second and Third Issue Revenues, Sale 1137, Lot 1299, Realized $35,000
6/27/2024, Siegel Auction Galleries, Inc., 2024 Raritites of the World, Sale 1326, Lot 4229, Realized $30,680

Certificates:

PF 386181 (2002)

2-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "J&B, Aug 30, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Minor paper wrinkle.

Provenance:

Richard Friedberg, List #27
1/28-30/1980, Harmers SF, Lot 600

Certificates:

3-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "St. P&C Ry, By RS, V Pr.". Manuscript and cut cancels.
Fault: Tiny thin speck at top.

Provenance:

10/27-28/1989, Cee Jay, Lot 57
6/16/2007, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2007 Rarities of the World, Sale 937, Lot 336, Realized $12,500

Certificates:

PF 455033

3-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "St P & C Ry, By RS, V pr.". Manuscript and cut cancels.
Fault: Tiny flaws.

Provenance:

4/24/1982, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1982 Rarities of the World, Sale 596, Lot 395, Realized $10,000
2/9/1983, Aldrich, Lot 465
10/12/1983, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenues: Essays, Proofs and Stamps, Sale 624, Lot 614
10/2-3/1984, Kelleher, Lot 1545
2/8/1986, Suburban, Lot 197

Certificates:

3-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "St P & C Ry, By RS, V pr.". Manuscript and cut cancels.
Fault: Couple light creases.

Provenance:

5/25/1986, Isleham Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Isleham Collection of United States Stamps, Sale 662, Lot 1338, Realized $5,500
3/17/1987, Kelleher, Lot 1167
12/9-11/1988, Ivy, Lot 1961
4/15/1989, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1989 Rarities of the World, Sale 708, Lot 427, Realized $7,000
3/10-12/2010, Spink Shreves Galleries, Lot 1052

Certificates:

PF 210013

3-4
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "St P & C Ry, By RS, V pr.". Manuscript, cut and embossed seal cancels.
Fault: Repaired tear.

Provenance:

7/29-30/1975, Mozian, Lot 1181
4/23/1983, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1983 Rarities of the World, Sale 618, Lot 261, Realized $5,500
3/7-8/1997, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 1164
10/17-18/2003, Dr. Claiborne Johnson Collection, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 288, Realized $6,500

Certificates:

3-5
Sound

Notes:

Only manuscript cancel. Manuscript and cut cancels.

Provenance:

1/10-11/1992, Dutch Country, Lot 547
3/18-20/1993, Ivy, Shreve & Mader, Lot 2706
6/30/2015, Fleishman Family Collection, Kelleher, Sale 670, Lot 43, Realized $10,500
5/2-4/2017, Kelleher, Sale 698, Lot 2684, Realized $11,000

Certificates:

PF 256877 (1992)

3-6
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "St P&C Ry, By RS, V pr.". Manuscript and cut cancels.

Provenance:

3/31/1976, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1976 Rarities of the World, Sale 489, Lot 270, Realized $3,000
11/20-21/1981, Stolow, Lot 2265
12/11/1999, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 794, Realized $8,500

Certificates:

PF (1976)

3-7
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "St P&C Ry, By RS, Vp.". Manuscript and cut cancels.

Provenance:

11/14/1963, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States, Sale 265, Lot 1574
4/8-9/2005, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Sale 68, Lot 1175, Realized $15,000

Certificates:

3-8
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "St P&C Ry, By RS Vpr.". Manuscript and cut cancels.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book.

Provenance:

Golden Oak Collection
6/16/2007, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2007 Rarities of the World, Sale 937, Lot 335, Realized $24,000
12/17-18/2013, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Golden Oak Collection of Superb United States, Sale 1062, Lot 897, Realized $21,000

Certificates:

PF 518271
PF (2007)

4-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "1872, July 2, SA & ?". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease

Provenance:

Himpsl Collection
11/14/1973, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Katharine Matthies Collection of U.S. & British Commonwealth, Sale 439, Lot 405
6/23/1976, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps 19th and 20th Century, Sale 494, Lot 1433
12/7/1991, Aldrich, Lot 271
8/19-20/2011, Spink Shreves Galleries, Sale 136, Lot 680, Realized $10,500
7/18-19/2012, Spink Shreves Galleries, Sale 140, Lot 394, Realized $11,000

Certificates:

4-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "1872, July 2, SA & St?". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Two pinholes and light horizontal crease.

Provenance:

3/25/1975, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1975 Rarities of the World, Sale 468, Lot 223, Realized $2,900
6/21-22/1988, Kelleher, Lot 2032

Certificates:

PF 529564

4-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "1872, July 2, SA & ?". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Two horizontal creases.

Provenance:

8/22-24/1986, Ivy, Lot 2010, Realized $7,500

Certificates:

PF 165760

5-1
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "ARC & I Co., July 9/72". Only manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

Scarsdale Collection
4/20/1985, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1985 Rarities of the World, Sale 645, Lot 364, Realized $8,500
3/13/1993, Ivy, Shreve & Mader, Lot 695
11/3/2011, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Scarsdale Collection, Part 6: U.S. Revenues, Sale 1015, Lot 89, Realized $21,000
2/29/2024, Dragonfly Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Dragonfly Collection of U.S. Revenue Stamps, Sale 1311, Lot 1080, Realized S24,780

Certificates:

PF 274322 (1995) Genuine
PF 381467 (2002) Genuine
PF 381-467-01 (2002) Genuine
PF 574255 (2021) Genuine

5-2
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "ARC & I Co., July 9/72". Only manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

9/18/1992, Ivy, Shreve & Mader, Lot 793
10/5/2016, Inman Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Grant Inman Collection, Part 3: First, Second and Third Issue Revenues, Sale 1137, Lot 1300, Realized $13,500

Certificates:

PF 106676 (1982) It is genuine

5-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "ARC & I Co., July 9/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Vertical crease at bottom right.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book.

Provenance:

Hancock Collection
4/11/2005, Goldberg, Sale 29, Lot 710, Realized $11,000
10/21-24/2010, Kelleher, Sale 622, Lot 2746, Realized $12,500
6/18/2011, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2011 Rarities of the World, Sale 1010, Lot 162, Realized $11,000

Certificates:

PSE (2004)

6-1
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "FBG". Only manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

9/22/1982, Aldrich, Lot 317
3/30/1985, Aldrich, Lot 424
3/30/1989, Aldrich, Lot 442

Certificates:

6-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "FBG". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Tiny thin speck and light horizontal crease.

Provenance:

Wyer Collection
1/6-7/1966, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S. Covers & U.S. Revenues, Sale 294, Lot 483
10/4-5/1977, Kelleher, Lot 1556
9/21/2004, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 881, Lot 1684, Realized $12,500

Certificates:

6-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "FBG Prest, per GHB K&P, Feb 1/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Partly reperfed at left and right, horizontal and corner creases.

Provenance:

4/13-14/1983, Quality, Lot 1057
2012, Eric Jackson Retail, Realized $17,500

Certificates:

PF 118803

6-4
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "FBG Prest, per GHB K&P, 1 Feb/72". Only manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

9/12/1992, Aldrich, Lot 280
3/12-13/1993, Aldrich, Lot 639
10/19/2005, Siegel Auction Galleries, Rare and Superb United States Stamps, Sale 902, Lot 1363, Realized $11,500
6/23-25/2008, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 959, Lot 3275, Realized $21,000

Certificates:

PF (2005)

6-5
Fault

Notes:

Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Internal tear (thin), scissor blunted perfs at top right.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book.

Provenance:

Hancock Collection
4/11/2005, Goldberg, Sale 29, Lot 711, Realized $8,800

Certificates:

PSE (2004)

7-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "?, 8/31/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Light corner crease at top left, tiny thin spot at center.

Provenance:

2/13/1962, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Philip Little Jr. Collection of U.S. Revenue Stamps, Sale 248, Lot 965
12/8/2010, Siegel Auction Galleries, Siegel Sale 1000, Sale 1000, Lot 1323, Realized $9,000

Certificates:

PSE (2001)

8-1
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "Consolidated Coal Co., Jany 1/72". Only manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

2/13-16/1967, Harmers NY, Lot 1805
10/25-26/1968, Kelleher, Lot 993
4/7/1990, Aldrich, Lot 458

Certificates:

PF 225281

8-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Con Coal Co., Jany 1/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Corner crease and few thin spots.

Provenance:

10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 702
3/22-23/1983, Kelleher, Lot 1368
3/27/2018, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States and Possessions, Sale 1179, Lot 2699, Realized $9,000

Certificates:

APS 135530 (2001)

9-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "PPM, July 8, 1872". Manuscript and cut cancels.
Fault: Large filled thin at center and repaired cut cancel.

Provenance:

10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 703
4/24-25/1998, Wampler Collection, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Sale 26, Lot 683, Realized $4,750
4/11-14/2013, Kelleher, Sale 636, Lot 644, Realized $11,000
6/4-6/2015, H.R. Harmer, Sale 3007, Lot 3554, Realized $11,000

Certificates:

10-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Charles ?, Treas, Aug 1, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Corner crease.

Provenance:

11/24/1959, Bruce G. Daniels, Lot 812
10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 697
9/13/1983, Kelleher, Lot 1253

Certificates:

11-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "BH Mertin, President, January 7th, 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Small thin speck at bottom.

Provenance:

Tolman Collection
6/19-20/1945, Mozian, Lot 142
10/17-19/1960, Harmers NY, Lot 477
6/27/2006, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Henry Tolman II Collection of U.S. Revenues-Part One, Sale 915, Lot 3533, Realized $13,500

Certificates:

12-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "? RR Co., 23 July 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Trimmed perfs on all sides and small closed tear at top.

Provenance:

1985, Golden Philatelics Price List, Lot 1540
4/3-4/1985, Apfelbaum, Lot 270
6/23-25/1994, Ivy, Shreve & Mader, Lot 1702

Certificates:

PF (1965)

12-2
Fault

Notes:

July 23, 1872 manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

6/4/1969, Herman Herst Collection, Lot 143

Certificates:

PSE 00089611 (2003) It is genuine with vertical crease and reperforated on all four sides

12-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "? RR Co., 23 July 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Crease at right and reperfed on all sides.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book.

Provenance:

6/4/1969, Herman Herst Collection, Lot 143
8/10-12/2007, Harmer Schau, Sale 73, Lot 2238, Realized $4,600

Certificates:

PF 449654

13-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "GBN, July 2/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Pinholes, tiny scuff, vertical crease at top, paper split at bottom.

Provenance:

Hall Collection
1/18/21, Harmers NY, Lot 1409
3/31/1984, Kaufmann, Lot 647
12/8/1984, Kaufmann, Lot 442
9/10-11/1992, Christies, Lot 610
4/28-30/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Robert R. Hall Collection of Outstanding United States Stamps, Sale 1096, Lot 979, Realized $12,500

Certificates:

14-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Light crease.

Provenance:

3/28/1968, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1968 Rarities of the World, Sale 330, Lot 200, Realized $1,850
10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 699
4/9-12/1980, R. Wolffers, Lot 1885
10/6-7/1982, Kelleher, Lot 1025
10/23-24/1998, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Sale 29, Lot 1618, Realized $7,250

Certificates:

14-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease at bottom.

Provenance:

6/8/1982, Harmers SF, Lot 1512

Certificates:

PF 471757

14-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Crease and short perfs at bottom.

Provenance:

4/19/1972, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S., U.S. Possessions and General Foreign, Sale 411, Lot 946
4/9/1987, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenue Stamps, Sale 678, Lot 526

Certificates:

14-4
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
On original document.

Provenance:

11/17-18/1969, Harmers NY, Lot 955

Certificates:

14-5
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease.

Provenance:

6/4/1968, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Postage, Sale 335, Lot 1392
7/8-9/2011, Kelleher, Sale 625, Lot 1312, Unsold

Certificates:

PF 303603

14-6
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease at bottom.

Provenance:

Shellabear Collection
6/26-27/2008, Cunliffe Collection, Spink Shreves Galleries, Sale 103, Lot 593, Realized $13,000

Certificates:

PF 467151

14-7
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Light horizontal crease.

Provenance:

2/24/1965, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1965 Rarities of the World, Sale 283, Lot 157, Realized $1,100

Certificates:

14-8
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Hoboken Oct 2/71, Fred F Chambers, Secretary, M&E RR Co.". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book.

Provenance:

12/11/1999, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 795, Realized $7,000

Certificates:

15-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "SIA&RNB, PPH, 15/6/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Crease and small tear.

Provenance:

2/26-27/1971, Kelleher, Lot 1726
2/12-14/1980, Harmers NY, Lot 1420
4/15-17/2005, Rumsey, Sale 20, Lot 2489, Realized $8,000
6/26/2019, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2019 Rarities of the World, Sale 1205, Lot 2155, Realized $8,000
12/13/2023, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 1305, Lot 2810, Realized $12,390

Certificates:

APS 157684 (2004)

15-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "SIA&RNB, PPH, 15/6/72". Manuscript and cut cancels.
Fault: Horizontal crease, small tear and toned spot at top left.

Provenance:

3/13-16/1961, Harmers NY, Lot 1788
2/12-14/1980, Harmers NY, Lot 1419
1/20-22/2006, Harmer Schau, Sale 68, Lot 800, Realized $9,500

Certificates:

15-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "SIA&RNB, PPH, 15/6/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Creases and rubbing below "500".

Provenance:

10/12/1983, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenues: Essays, Proofs and Stamps, Sale 624, Lot 615
8/1-4/1984, Wolffers, Lot 2709

Certificates:

15-4
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "SIA&RNB, PPH, 15/6/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Repaired at right center, small pieces drawn in at bottom right, repair at top right.

Provenance:

10/15-17/1968, Harmers NY, Lot 1055
10/12/1983, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenues: Essays, Proofs and Stamps, Sale 624, Lot 616
10/2-3/1984, Kelleher, Lot 1546
7/31/1986, Fox, Lot 1066
3/6-7/1987, Metro-Simmy, Lot 1473
5/17/1987, Huntington, Lot 351
10/18-19/2002, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 1324, Realized $7,500

Certificates:

PF 391950

15-5
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "SIA&RNB, PPH, 15/6/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Repair at right.

Provenance:

9/30-10/1, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 1237, Realized $5,000
10/6-7/1964, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S. incl. Postmaster Provisionals, Unused 19th & 20th Century, Envelopes & Revenues, Sale 276, Lot 688
5/15/1999, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1999 Rarities of the World, Sale 811, Lot 264, Realized $4,750
6/1/2016, Rumsey, Sale 68, Lot 412, Realized $9,500

Certificates:

PF (2016)
PSE (2006)

16-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease and few short perfs.

Provenance:

11/30/1978, Phillips, Lot 227

Certificates:

16-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease.

Provenance:

6/11-12/1959, Mozian, Lot 674
9/13/1973, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States and General Foreign, Sale 436, Lot 762
12/2/1989, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Postal Stationery and Revenues, Sale 718, Lot 5192

Certificates:

16-3A-B
Fault
Before alteration

16-3A-B
Fault
After alteration

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease, thin, short perfs at left. Short perfs have since been repaired and manuscript "x" added.

Provenance:

Before alteration:
After alteration:
2/10-11/1979, S&A Auctions, Lot 686
5/5/1979, Kaufmann, Lot 831
3/15/1988, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States, British Commonwealth and General Foreign, Sale 690, Lot 767

Certificates:

16-4
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Creases.

Provenance:

10/16/1978, Sotheby Park Bernet, Lot 522

Certificates:

16-5
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Thin spot, horizontal crease, small filled in thins at top left and bottom left.
Signed Ackerman

Provenance:

2/9-10/1973, Kelleher, Lot 1132
5/14/2008, P. Weiss, Lot 183

Certificates:

PF 460812 (2008)

16-6
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Small flaws.

Provenance:

6/13/1991, Christies NY, Lot 1063

Certificates:

16-7
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "N. Hitchcock, Special Magistrate Court, Ot. 3, 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Thins at top corners and reperf at top.

Provenance:

9/30-10/1, Wolffers-2/1992, Lot 1680
10/1-2/1985, Kelleher, Lot 1628
3/5-6/1991, Kelleher, Lot 1600
3/16/1993, Kelleher, Lot 1022

Certificates:

17-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Robert C. Hutchings, Surrogate, September 10, 1872". Manuscript and cut (herringbone) cancels.
Fault: Light crease.

Provenance:

Kenedi, Sale 318, Lot 760, Realized $5,750
3/3/1970, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenue Stamps, Sale 368, Lot 216
4/24/1982, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1982 Rarities of the World, Sale 596, Lot 394, Realized $12,000
11/23/1982, Suburban, Lot 78
6/25/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2015 Rarities of the World, Sale 1106, Lot 3171, Realized $14,000

Certificates:

PF (1982)

17-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Robert C. Hutchings, Surrogate, September 10, 1872". Manuscript and cut (herringbone) cancel.
Fault: Crease and thin.

Provenance:

10/26/1966, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States 19th and 20th Century Proofs, Sale 307, Lot 1323
11/6/1985, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps and Postal History, Sale 652, Lot 1467
11/8-10/2018, Eastern Auctions, Lot 447, Realized C$8,000

Certificates:

17-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Robert C. Hutchings, Surrogate, September 10, 1872". Manuscript and cut (herringbone) cancels.
Fault: Light crease.

Provenance:

5/31/1972, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Postage and Revenues, Sale 413, Lot 527

Certificates:

18-1
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "R&I C & CI Co., April 1/72". Only manuscript cancel.

Provenance:

11/8/1989, Weill Stock, Christies NY, Lot 363
3/12-14/1992, Ivy, Shreve & Mader, Lot 6004
6/26/2014, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2014 Rarities of the World, Sale 1075, Lot 1218, Realized $14,000
1/10-11/2015, Regency, Sale 109, Lot 1853, Unsold
4/23-26/2015, Rumsey, Sale 60, Lot 2697, Unsold
3/7/2018, Siegel Auction Galleries, The J. R. Helton, Jr. Collection of Used United States Stamps, Sale 1174, Lot 362, Realized $16,500, J.R. Helton, Jr. Collection

Certificates:

PSE 01290175 (2014)
PF 217463 (1989)

18-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "R&I C & CI Co., April 1/72". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Small faults, reperf at top and left, cleaned.

Provenance:

9/11/1987, Stolow, Lot 618
2/27/2002, Siegel Auction Galleries, Outstanding U.S. Stamps, Sale 843, Lot 2432, Realized $7,500
12/16-19/2007, Bennett, Sale 325, Lot 2621, Realized $5,000
4/1/2008, Heritage, Sale 998325, Lot 2621, Realized $5,000

Certificates:

PF (2007)

19-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel not legible. Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Cancel lightened, trimmed and reperfed, rebacked.

Provenance:

9/9/1982, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States 19th and 20th Century, Sale 601, Lot 1120B

Certificates:

20-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel not legible. Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Light thins.

Provenance:

1/9/1975, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States and General Foreign, Sale 463, Lot 1016

Certificates:

21-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "RAS?, Feby 25 1872". Only manuscript cancel.
Light 1872 manuscript and four unobtrusive punch cancels that have been neatly filled or covered

Provenance:

3/24/1970, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1970 Rarities of the World, Sale 371, Lot 224, Realized $1,900
5/29/2020, World Traveler Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The World Traveler Collection of U.S. Revenues, Sale 1222, Lot 2051, Realized $9,500

Certificates:

22-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel not legible. Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Several creases and short perfs.

Provenance:

3/16/1991, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States 19th and 20th Century Stamps and Covers, Sale 735, Lot 923

Certificates:

23-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "CC, 25th, March, 1872". Manuscript and embossed cancels.
Fault: Small thin at bottom and tiny closed tear at left.

Provenance:

Cunliffe Collection
6/26-27/2008, Spink Shreves Galleries, Sale 103, Lot 594, Realized $10,500

Certificates:

24-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "The Cayuga, Lake Railroad, Company, Sept 15 1871". Only manuscript cancel.
Fault: Few light creases.

Provenance:

6/26-27/2008, Cunliffe Collection, Spink Shreves Galleries, Sale 103, Lot 595, Realized $14,500
10/4/2012, Schauss Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, Dr. Alexander Schauss Collection of U.S. Revenues, Sale 1031, Lot 1043, Realized $9,500
3/3/2020, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 1217, Lot 1433, Realized $10,500

Certificates:

25-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Union Gas Light Co., ?". Manuscript and punch cancels.
Fault: Repaired punch cancels and a few small thins.

Provenance:

10/14/1971, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, incl. The Estate of Robert Baughman, Sale 402, Lot 1385
3/18/2016, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenues incl. Hunting Permits, Sale 1121, Lot 2018, Realized $9,500

Certificates:

26-1
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Fault: Small thin spot at top left.

Provenance:

10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 701
10/14-16/1980, Harmers NY, Lot 1141
3/17-19/1981, Kelleher, Lot 2210
10/28/1989, Aldrich, Lot 678
10/24/2012, Bulkley Collection, Rumsey, Sale 48, Lot 84, Unsold

Certificates:

PF (1980)

26-2
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Fault: Light horizontal crease.

Provenance:

2/13/1962, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Philip Little Jr. Collection of U.S. Revenue Stamps, Sale 248, Lot 966
10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 700
1992, Aldrich Mail Price Sale, Lot 77
3/12-13/1993, Aldrich, Lot 640

Certificates:

PF 149748

26-3
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Fault: Tiny thin spot and crease.

Provenance:

5/9-10/1938, Am. Art Association (W.S. Scott), Lot 95
4/29/1981, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1981 Rarities of the World, Sale 579, Lot 471, Realized $16,500
1992, Aldrich Net Sale, Lot 72
9/12/1992, Aldrich, Lot 279

Certificates:

PF 151277

26-4
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Fault: Small thin spots and minor corner crease.

Provenance:

4/16/1988, Suburban, Lot 504
9/27/1994, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps and Covers, Sale 761, Lot 1522, Unsold
4/1/2008, Heritage, Sale 998326, Lot 834, Realized $11,500
4/16-17/2008, Bennett, Sale 326, Lot 834, Realized $11,500
11/1/2008, Heritage, Sale 998268, Lot 1354, Realized $9,500

Certificates:

26-5
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Fault: Small faint corner crease at top left.

Provenance:

6/26-27/2008, Cunliffe Collection, Spink Shreves Galleries, Sale 103, Lot 592, Realized $12,500
3/24/2014, "Wildhorse" Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Wildhorse Collection of U.S. Revenues and Encased Postage, Sale 1066, Lot 89, Realized $14,000
1/12/2016, Kelleher, Sale 677, Lot 391, Realized $11,000

Certificates:

26-6
Sound

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Example is not listed in Kingsley book.

Provenance:

Beverly Hills Collection
11/12/2007, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 946, Lot 1543, Realized $18,000
6/23-25/2008, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 959, Lot 3274, Realized $16,000
12/4/2009, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Beverly Hills Collection of Outstanding United States Stamps, Sale 978, Lot 1177, Realized $19,000

Certificates:

PSE (2008), Graded 70
PF (2007)

26-7
Fault

Notes:

Cancel reads "Surrogate, County of, New York". Manuscript and handstamp cancels. Handstamp reading "Surrogate Office, New York".
Fault: Small surface scuff at center left.
Example is not listed in Kingsley book.

Provenance:

11/19/2013, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 1061, Lot 4308, Realized $16,000
3/14/2024, Eugene L. Grace Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Eugene L. Grace Collection of United States and Confederate States Stamps and Covers, Sale 1315, Lot 5842, Realized $24,780

Certificates:

PF 516758 (2014) Genuine with a small surface scuff at the left edge of the central vignette

27-1
Fault

Notes:

Handstamp and cut (herringbone) cancels.
Fault: Tear and horizontal crease.

Provenance:

Summer 1985, Aldirch Net Price, Lot 504
9/9-10/1981, Robson Lowe, Lot 664
12/4/1982, Kaufmann, Lot 145
3/31/1984, Kaufmann, Lot 648
12/2/1985, Aldirch, Lot 865

Certificates:

27-2
Fault

Notes:

Cut (herringbone) cancel.
Fault: Couple tiny thin specks.

Provenance:

Golden Price List No. 8
4/21/1983, Christies, Lot 309
4/9/1987, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenue Stamps, Sale 678, Lot 527
4/15/1989, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1989 Rarities of the World, Sale 708, Lot 428, Realized $6,250
2/6/2004, Heritage, Sale 998272, Lot 2399, Realized $7,250
1/18-20/2006, Bennett, Sale 299, Lot 3688, Realized $7,000
10/21-22/2016, Bennett, Sale 354, Lot 502, Realized $9,500
6/27/2017, Siegel Auction Galleries, 2017 Rarities of the World, Sale 1159, Lot 293, Realized $7,500

Certificates:

27-3
Fault

Notes:

Handstamp and cut (herringbone) cancels.
Few faults including punch hole filled in

Provenance:

5/15-16/1961, Harmers NY, Lot 1220
4/14/1983, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Revenue Stamps, Sale 617, Lot 273

Certificates:

27-4
Fault

Notes:

Handstamp cancels.
Fault: Faults and repaired.

Provenance:

9/11-12/1991, Christies NY, Lot 884
1992, Stanley Piller, Private Treaty

Certificates:

27-5
Fault

Notes:

Cut (herringbone) cancel.
Fault: Top right corner repaired.
Example is not listed in Kingsley Book.

Provenance:

5/20/1994, Siegel Auction Galleries, U.S. & Foreign Stamps & Covers, Sale 760, Lot 1619, Realized $5,250
1/12-14/2018, Harmer-Schau, Sale 115, Lot 980, Realized $8,000

Certificates:

PSE (2017)

28-1
Sound

Notes:

Handstamp and cut cancel.

Provenance:

Cole Collection
Lyons Collection
5/10/1988, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Clifford C. Cole, Jr. Collection - U.S. Back of Book and Confederate States, Sale 693, Lot 547
1/21-22/2000, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 880, Realized $8,500

Certificates:

PF 512292
PSE (1999)

28-2
Sound

Notes:

Handstamp and cut cancels.

Provenance:

10/16-18/1979, Harmers NY, Lot 698
11/12/1988, Suburban, Lot 496

Certificates:

28-3
Sound

Notes:

Cut cancel.

Provenance:

Joyce Collection
6/4-6/1991, Kelleher, Lot 2640
8/20-22/2015, Harmer-Schau, Sale 106, Lot 2220, Realized $14,000

Certificates:

28-4
Fault

Notes:

Cut cancel.
Fault: Horizontal crease.

Provenance:

4/5/1986, Siegel Auction Galleries, 1986 Rarities of the World, Sale 660, Lot 342, Realized $6,750
10/24-26/2017, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 1166, Lot 1349, Realized $10,500

Certificates:

28-5
Sound

Notes:

Cut cancel.

Provenance:

9/10/1975, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps - The Schedler Collection, Sale 476, Lot 540
2/19-20/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, Outstanding United States Stamps, Sale 1092, Lot 1515, Realized $16,000

Certificates:

PF (1975)

28-6
Sound

Notes:

Cut cancel.

Provenance:

10/29/1964, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Edwin A. Flanders Collection of United States Postage and Revenue Stamps, Sale 277, Lot 405

Certificates:

28-7
Sound

Notes:

Cut cancel.

Provenance:

Connoisseur Collection
Curtis Collection
7/2-3/1982, Kaufmann, Lot 68
10/26-27/1992, Superior, Lot 681
3/16/1993, Kelleher, Lot 1021
12/16/2014, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Curtis Collection: U.S. Revenues, Part 1, Sale 1089, Lot 474, Realized $23,000
6/22/2015, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps and Covers, Sale 1100, Lot 182, Realized $20,000

Certificates:

PF 529653
PF (1974)

28-8
Fault

Notes:

Cut cancel.
Fault: Tiny thin spot.

Provenance:

Joyce Collection
3/18-19/1986, Christies NY, Lot 609
9/14/2000, Zoellner Collection, Siegel Auction Galleries, The Robert Zoellner and Henry Tolman Collections of U.S. Revenues, Sale 827, Lot 1612, Realized $8,000
10/23-25/2001, Floyd Collection, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 1769, Realized $10,500
2/27/2007, Siegel Auction Galleries, United States Stamps, Sale 930, Lot 2935, Realized $19,000
4/27-30/2017, Rumsey, Sale 74, Lot 2408, Realized $11,000

Certificates:

PF (2001)

29-1
Sound

Notes:

Cut (herringbone) cancel.

Provenance:

10/30-1/1990, Harmers NY, Lot 579

Certificates:

PF 234103

30-1
Fault

Notes:

Manuscript cancel only.
Fault: Repair at top left.
Example not listed in Kingsley book.

Provenance:

1/23/1998, Shreves Philatelic Galleries, Lot 1407, Realized $5,250

Certificates:

Back to Census Summary of R133

Back to the Siegel Census

Census of $500.00 Red Orange, Green & Black, Second Issue, "Large Persian Rug" (Scott R133)87 Census Records

1-1 Sound

1-2 Sound

1-3 Sound

2-1 Fault

3-1 Fault

3-2 Fault

3-3 Fault

3-4 Fault

3-5 Sound

3-6 Sound

3-7 Sound

3-8 Sound

4-1 Fault

4-2 Fault

4-3 Fault

5-1 Sound

5-2 Sound

5-3 Fault

6-1 Sound

6-2 Fault

6-3 Fault

6-4 Sound

6-5 Fault

7-1 Fault

8-1 Sound

8-2 Fault

9-1 Fault

10-1 Fault

11-1 Fault

12-1 Fault

12-2 Fault

12-3 Fault

13-1 Fault

14-1 Fault

14-2 Fault

14-3 Fault

14-4 Sound

14-5 Fault

14-6 Fault

14-7 Fault

14-8 Fault

15-1 Fault

15-2 Fault

15-3 Fault

15-4 Fault

15-5 Fault

16-1 Fault

16-2 Fault

16-3A-B Fault Before alteration

16-3A-B Fault After alteration

16-4 Fault

16-5 Fault

16-6 Fault

16-7 Fault

17-1 Fault

17-2 Fault

17-3 Fault

18-1 Sound

18-2 Fault

19-1 Fault

20-1 Fault

21-1 Fault

22-1 Fault

23-1 Fault

24-1 Fault

25-1 Fault

26-1 Fault

26-2 Fault

26-3 Fault

26-4 Fault

26-5 Fault

26-6 Sound

26-7 Fault

27-1 Fault

27-2 Fault

27-3 Fault

27-4 Fault

27-5 Fault

28-1 Sound

Census of $500.00 Red Orange, Green & Black, Second Issue, "Large Persian Rug" (Scott R133)
87 Census Records

1-1
Sound

1-2
Sound

1-3
Sound

2-1
Fault

3-1
Fault

3-2
Fault

3-3
Fault

3-4
Fault

3-5
Sound

3-6
Sound

3-7
Sound

3-8
Sound

4-1
Fault

4-2
Fault

4-3
Fault

5-1
Sound

5-2
Sound

5-3
Fault

6-1
Sound

6-2
Fault

6-3
Fault

6-4
Sound

6-5
Fault

7-1
Fault

8-1
Sound

8-2
Fault

9-1
Fault

10-1
Fault

11-1
Fault

12-1
Fault

12-2
Fault

12-3
Fault

13-1
Fault

14-1
Fault

14-2
Fault

14-3
Fault

14-4
Sound

14-5
Fault

14-6
Fault

14-7
Fault

14-8
Fault

15-1
Fault

15-2
Fault

15-3
Fault

15-4
Fault

15-5
Fault

16-1
Fault

16-2
Fault

16-3A-B
Fault
Before alteration

16-3A-B
Fault
After alteration

16-4
Fault

16-5
Fault

16-6
Fault

16-7
Fault

17-1
Fault

17-2
Fault

17-3
Fault

18-1
Sound

18-2
Fault

19-1
Fault

20-1
Fault

21-1
Fault

22-1
Fault

23-1
Fault

24-1
Fault

25-1
Fault

26-1
Fault

26-2
Fault

26-3
Fault

26-4
Fault

26-5
Fault

26-6
Sound

26-7
Fault

27-1
Fault

27-2
Fault

27-3
Fault

27-4
Fault

27-5
Fault

28-1
Sound